After considering hundreds of options and spending more than 50 hours testing, it's clear that Lelo Loki is the best all-round anal sex toy for men who want to enjoy prostate orgasms.
It's smooth, easy to insert and remove and has plenty of different vibration settings to make sure you get a level of stimulation that works for you.
What is an anal sex toy?
Anal sex toys are specifically designed to simulate the areas within your anus that trigger pleasure.
Although anal toys are for men and women, the benefits are greater for men as the prostate gland has a huge number of nerves that can result in an orgasm.
Prostate massagers, also known as prostate stimulators, are anal sex toys designed to massage a man's prostate gland, helping to release built up fluids and achieve body orgasms.
There are two main types of massager available:
The key benefit of using a standard prostate massager is that it is more likely to stay in place when used hands-free. This is good if you want to masturbate or have sex while using it.
By tensing your kegel muscles, the device naturally hits your prostate and gives you an orgasm.
Vibrating prostate massagers have a much greater intensity level, giving you more stimulation, however, they have a tendency to become dislodged due motion. For that reason it's best to hold them in place or have your partner join in the fun.
Note: some people argue that butt plugs should be considered prostate massagers, however these sex toys are only designed to sit inside your anus, not to to stimulate your prostate glands.
The 5 best Anal Sex Toys for 2021
We’ll start with a quick rundown of the top products, then we’ll move onto the science behind how prostate massaging works, how we compared the top devices and finally, we'll answer the most common questions.
Comparison table of the 5 best brands:
Anal Sex Toy
Anero Vice 2
Anero Helix Syn
The scores from this table are based on: intensity, durability, materials used and ease of use.
Why buy the Lelo Loki?
- Simple & durable
Many prostate stimulators attempt to overcomplicate the massaging process with features that are good in theory, but often break down and end up in the bin. The Lelo Loki's simple, yet premium design ensures that it won't let you down when you need it most.
- Shape & Size
With an insertable length of 100mm and a width of 42mm, some guys get weary of its size, however this feature is actually a big plus because its more likely to hit your prostate gland and result in an orgasm.
- High intensity levels
The Lelo Loki is the top prostate massager for intense vibrations. Calling this device a 'toy' is an understatement. It packs some serious stimulation! The orgasm you'll experience from it will have you utterly shook and you'll probably need to take a couple of days off of sex as your prostate will be all milked out.
- Luxury Materials
Unpacking this device, you'll quickly realise that you're working with a premium piece of kit. The materials used feel soft yet firm on your skin and all of the buttons do exactly what they intend to without delay.
- Customer Testimonials
Going through the 100s testimonials online, you'll find more positive experiences with this device than any other. In fact, many people start on other prostate stimulators and then graduate up to the Lelo Loki when they realise they can get more power with it. If you're at the start of your prostate orgasm journey, surely it would be much better to just go with the best option right away?
- Excellent Customer Support
Visiting the Lelo Loki website, you'll notice a chat window pop up with a very attentive support staff who give you great advice on how to use the device properly.
- Works Hands-Free
Unlike many vibrating prostate stimulator toys, the Loki stays in place even when you're not holding onto it.
Are there any downsides?
The only real downside to the Loki is its lack of focus on your prostate so at the lower intensity levels you feel less stimulation.
Why buy the Anero Vice 2?
- Ridged Shaft
The team behind Vice 2 made an interesting observation before they created this brand; no other prostate massagers are built to accommodate the body's natural inner-ridges. With the knowledge that nothing else like this existed on the market, they created a product with minutely details nubs and rims that when inserted into the anus causes an incredible stimulation all around you.
- Range Of Settings
With a whopping 18 speed settings available, it means that you can gradually build up the intensity levels from a low, barely noticeable whirr to a mind-blowing spasm that will have you moving uncontrollably.
- Wireless Controller
Giving your partner access to the wireless controller is quite a thrill. Without having the power to decide the intensity level yourself, it helps you to get closer to an orgasm.
Are there any downsides?
- Less Intensity
Although the intensity provided by the Aneros Vice 2 is strong enough to get you to achieve a substantial orgasm, it's not the most intense prostate massager on the market.
- Needs remote to function
If the remote controller breaks or runs out of batteries during use of this device, it basically renders it useless as there are no localized control functions.
Why Lelo Billy gets our thumbs up
On the other end of the spectrum is the Lelo Billy. Instead of focusing on lots of different ridges and edges that stimulate you all around, this brand focuses on staying as smooth as possible. The logic behind this is simple, by keeping the number of edges to a minimum, it helps you to decide where to apply the vibrations most. If you want to push directly on your prostate gland then this is the best product for you.
Are there any downsides?
Although the Lelo Billy is a great choice for people who are new to prostate massaging toys, it's unlikely to provide the stimulation that intermediate or advanced users seek.
Why the Helix Syn gets our thumbs up
- Doesn't Fall Out
Looking for a simple hands-free prostate massager that you can use while having sex? Although other hands-free brands exist, Helix Syn is the best at maintaining a consistent position inside you. Why should you care about that? Well, it's extremely frustrating when you find a good spot that could set you off but you can't have sex in fear that the massager will move and you'll lose it. With the Helix Syn you do not need to worry about that.
- No Batteries Required
If you're regularly travelling, it can be a real hassle to remember to charge your massager after every use. Instead of vibration, the Helix Syn works through kegel exercises. Every time you tense, you feel your prostate gland getting touched by the toy, bringing you closer to orgasm.
- Multiple Points Of Stimulation
The Helix Syn hits 3 erogenous points: the prostate, the perineum and the scrotum to heighten the experience and give you even more pleasure.
Are there any downsides?
The stimulation that you get from the Helix Syn comes from the squeezing together of your kegel muscles. However, if you're not used to doing these exercises, it can be some time before you achieve an orgasm.
Benefits Of Using Anal Toys
The benefits of using penis rings are so overwhelmingly big that it's a surprise they aren't used by every guy during sex.
Another awesome reason to buy a ring is that your erections will be slightly bigger. The extra blood coursing through your penis will mean it's swollen to its largest point.
The most well-known benefit of using cock rings is that they help you to overcome ED. By slowing the flow of blood going back to your body from your penis, it helps you stay hard for longer.
Most guys think these sex toys are all about giving their partners better sex, but the truth is, there's a lot of pleasure to be had out of wearing them too!
Types Of Anal Sex Toy For Men
There's more to anal toys that just putting them in your butt and moving them back and forth. Depending on your personal preferences, you might decide to select one of the following 4 categories:
Butt plugs are the simplest anal toy to use. They're focus is less on the stimulation you get from motion and more about the feeling you get from having a toy pressed against your prostate. In terms of appearance, they are typically kept basic and non-fleshy.
Selecting a dildo for anal use requires more forethought than purchasing one for vaginal use.
Make sure that your dildo has a large, flared base. This will ensure the dildo is easy to hold and that it stays outside of the body for easy removal.
Please also pay attention to the diameter of your toy. Anal beginners are going to want a diameter between 0.75" and 1.5". Many dildos are larger than that, but the Skyn dildo by Sportsheets fits the bill. Dildos Just like vaginal dildos, anal dildos are just any dildos that you choose to use anally.
Not only are these great as practice for couples who would like to engage in anal intercourse, they also provide an intense feeling of "fullness" that a lot of people enjoy.
These types of anal toys also make it very simple to experience the pleasurable sensation of thrusting with an anal toy. Selecting a dildo for anal use requires more forethought than purchasing one for vaginal use.
Make sure that your dildo has a large, flared base. This will ensure the dildo is easy to hold and that it stays outside of the body for easy removal. Please also pay attention to the diameter of your toy. Anal beginners are going to want a diameter between 0.75" and 1.5". Many dildos are larger than that, but the Skyn dildo by Sportsheets fits the bill.
A strand of small beads attached together on a long strand, anal beads are inserted into the butt one-at-a-time. Lots of people enjoy the sensation of the body readjusting with each new insertion.
For that reason, many anal beads are created with a gradually expanding diameter. As you insert each bead, the beads get larger and larger.
Many anal bead toys are also equipped with a simple handle to remove the beads when you're finished using them.
When selecting anal beads, make sure your beads are high-quality and very durable.
You don't want your strand of beads to break mid-use. Try a simple set of silicone anal beads.
Generally regarded as best for those who have a penis, prostate massagers help massage the prostate from inside the butt.
Some prostate massagers are designed to be toys you can use like dildos while other prostate massagers were specifically designed to be hands-free; the internal tightening and clenching of muscles will gently massage the toy pleasurably into the prostate.
Many prostate massagers also come equipped with perineum nubs for added pleasure.
A few toys to try in this category include the very highly rated LELO HUGO, the We-Vibe Dusk Pleasure Mate and the LELO LOKI Wave.
Of course, if you're new to any type of anal pleasure, you may want to consider looking into a "beginner anal kit."
These kits include multiple types of anal toys to let a newbie experience different types of pleasure with ease. Some kits also include similar toys of various diameters; this will allow you to slowly increase the size of toys you're comfortable playing with.
No matter whether you want to use just your fingers, purchase a kit full of toys, or just experiment with a single type of toy, anal toys can open up your sexual repertoire to include a whole lot more pleasure.
What to consider when buying anal sex toys
Since they come in a whole host of shapes and sizes, it can be difficult deciding what's most important to you. Here's what I believe you should consider...
For those need for a gentle and passionate anal experience, the rubber or silicone anal toys are perfect. Their shape must be close to the penis shape, and their texture must be soft and slippery.
In such cases, a classic anal toy from silicone or rubber should be enough for a smashing anal experience. For those willing for a more adventurous anal experience, a stiff thrusting anal toy or a rotating anal toy should come in handy for their kinky desires.
These are often made out of jelly rubber or skin-safe rubber, and they provide a more realistic feel and texture. For those moody for the ultimate anal adventure, experienced and skilled, the luxury anal toys made out of steel or glass should be the right choice.
These toys are rigid and very stiff, suitable for users already used with the sensation of anal masturbation. Their texture is rigid and hard, perfect for a kinky couple or for a highly aroused user. There toys also have a variety of shapes, some including veins to simulate the feeling of a real penis . The shape and texture are highly important factors when choosing your anal toy.
Rubber, silicone, plastic, steel, glass We determined our testing criteria using feedback from experts and a diverse pool of sex-toy users. These criteria were: It had to be made from nonporous, body-safe material.
A toy should be smooth and comfortable to use, with a good shape that’s not painful, too large, or too small. A flared base so it cannot become lost in the anal cavity. Ergonomic design that’s easy to use, wear, insert, and remove. An easy-to-clean toy that doesn’t retain bacteria or scent.
Either you want a rotating anal toy, a inflatable or a classic anal toy, choosing the right size will help you experience the best experiences and results. If the size is bigger than you can handle, risks might appear, such as pain, pressure and unwanted stimulation.
If the size is small, you might feel unsatisfied and frustrated by your choice. A simple guide on choosing and using anal toys should be enough for you to learn how to choose the right size but here are some tips to come in handy: beginner - start with small toys go bigger if you have tried small toys already larger is not always better check reviews and size charts
Proper information and guidance on using anal toys will be the most effective way for you to choose the right size. Since these toys can have from 3-4 inches up to 13+ inches, it’s pretty hard to tell which is the right size, but according to most users, the most common size for adult toys for anal is 5 inches.
You should also factor in budget when considering a cock ring. They typically range from $10 to $150 but super high-end ones can rocket into the thousands!
Ease of use
There's nothing worse than buying a new sex toy and realising that it's a hassle to operate. When simple functions like turning it on and off, changing the vibration settings and removing it from your anus are difficult, then it can putt you off using it.
Cheap prostate massagers often do not take the same level of care in their manufacturing process as the luxury brands and, for that reason, it's wise to pay a little bit extra.
Frequently Asked Questions
How to prepare for using an anal sex toy
Unlike masturbation, a thorough prostate massage requires a decent amount of preparation to ensure everything goes smoothly. Take the following steps for best results:
- Allocate at least an hour: the first thing you've got to bear in mind is that this process takes a bit of time to prepare for, then it takes time to do the massage and finally, it takes time to clean up. For that reason, it's important that you budget at least an hour of your day where you will have no interruptions.
- Clean & calm environment: a lot of the experience is based on calming your mind and letting your prostate sync with the vibrations from the prostate stimulator, however if you're feeling at all anxious then you can forget they are there and not achieve the desired result.
- Bowel movement: before you do anything else, go to the toilet and relieve yourself to get rid of any feces in your anus.
- Anal douching: give your anus a thorough clean using an anal douche (you can also use the high-power setting of your shower, however this is less effective).
- Lay down a towel in the place: this stops you from getting any remaining fecal matter on your bed, carpet or flooring.
- Finger first: apply a generous amount of lubrication to your finger, rub it around your anus and then insert it to warm yourself up.
- You are now ready for your prostate stimulator.
How To Clean An Anal Sex Toy
Keeping your anal toys clean is extremely important, especially if you are sharing your toys with partners. We don’t recommended using toys made from porous materials anally, as they can retain bacteria from the rectal cavity. We recommend that your cover your toys with a condom when sharing them with partners, especially if it’s someone you are not fluid-bonded with (i.e. you typically use barriers for other types of sexual activities). A toy that is used both anally and vaginally should also be covered to prevent transferring bacteria from the anus to the vagina. Waterproof toys made from nonporous materials like silicone and stainless steel can be washed with soap and warm water.
Non-waterproof toys can be carefully wiped clean with a solution of soap and warm water. Spray-on toy cleanser can be useful for toys that cannot be submerged. It is generally not necessary to disinfect toys that are only used by one person or covered with condoms, but there are several techniques that work well if desired. Some non-motorized 100 percent silicone and stainless steel toys can be boiled or put in the top rack of the dishwasher without detergent to be steam sanitized. Waterproof toys of all stripes can be soaked in 10 percent bleach solution for 10 minutes to disinfect and thoroughly washed with soap and water afterwards.
We do not recommend these techniques for glass and wooden toys, as they are more fragile and prone to breakage.
We recommend that toys be stored in boxes or pouches to remain dust-free in a cool, dark place where they will not be exposed to direct sunlight. Many high-end manufacturers include free cloth pouches or attractive storage boxes with the purchase of a toy.Several prominent sex educators have recently made claims that the interactions between silicone lube and toys are overstated, so we decided to conduct our own test.
The toys we tested included PleasureWorks’s Don Juan and Siren, Lelo’s Mona and Gigi, JimmyJane’s Form 2, the JeJoue Mimi, the Jopen Comet Wand, Doc Johnson’s Mood Naughty 1 and 2, and the Fun Factory Bootie.
We applied about a quarter’s worth of Uberlube silicone lubricant to a patch towards the bases of the toys, rubbed it into the surface of the toy for 1 minute to simulate friction, then left the toys to sit for an hour.
Following this experiment, we discovered that every single toy had been affected by the lube.
In some cases, the patch exposed to lube appeared raised. In the worst cases, the lube completely took the finish off the toy, causing it to become gummy, sticky, and blistered. In some cases the stickiness can be scrubbed off, but we do not recommend that silicone lubricants be used with silicone toys because we don’t know how these lubricants will affect the porosity and integrity of the toy over time.
Many high-end toy companies offer limited warranties or guarantees in case your toy breaks within a certain amount of time (typically one to three years).
In order to redeem your warranty, you will need to purchase the toy from a licensed retailer (due to problems with counterfeit toys sometimes being sold on Amazon and eBay) and save the receipt. If you’re looking for guidance on how to use anal toys, many good books have been written on the subject, including Tristan Taormino’s Ultimate Guide to Anal Sex for Women, Anal Pleasure & Health: A Guide for Men & Women by Jack Morin, and The Ultimate Guide to Prostate Pleasure by Charlie Glickman and Aislinn Emirzian.
Can anal sex toys cause problems?
There are a couple of situations where you can cause yourself damage through the use of a prostate massage. We'll discuss them now:
- Sharp, dirty nails: if you (or your partner) have particularly sharp nails, it can irritate the inside of your anus during the initial preparation stage. Make sure they are well-trimmed and cleaned before getting started.
- Lack of lubricant: the anus is not self-lubricating so it's imperative that you use plenty of lubrication prior to a prostate massage. If you do not use enough, it can result in irritation.
- When prostate massagers are too big: if you select a device that is too large for your anus then it can be uncomfortable.