Best Butt Plugs For Men Reviewed

By Charlie Chambers
Updated: 05 Sep 2021
Category: Anal Toys
Butt Plug

Want to add a little anal play to the bedroom but not ready to go all-in with a prostate massager?

By stimulating the nerve endings in your anus with a butt plug, it opens you up to a whole new world of pleasure.

And the best part is, they're shaped in a way that keeps them in a steady position, allowing you to do other fun things at the same time.

With lots of different types of butt plug to choose from, it can be a little daunting deciding which one is right for you.

To save you hours of searching, we've put together this comprehensive guide.

If you're excited to get started and would prefer to skip ahead to the best overall butt plug you'll find it below:

Top Rated

Best Butt Plug

njoy Pure Play XL

  • Sizeable Head
  • Luxury Stainless Steel
  • Smooth, Firm Finish
  • Wide Base For Safety
  • Hand Polished
  • Easily Hits Prostate

What is a butt plug?

A butt plug is an anal sex toy designed to stimulate the nerve endings inside the anus without being absorbed into the rectum. The base component acts as a safety mechanism to stop it from going in too far and causing you damage.

There are 10 different types of butt plug available:

  1. Beginner
  2. Extra Large
  3. Vibrating
  4. Electrified
  5. Jewelled
  6. Glass
  7. Metallic
  8. Tail
  9. Inflatable

Fact: Invented in the 1940s, the makers of the butt plug claimed they could help with all kinds of medical problems, however they did not take off until people started using them as sex toys.

The 9 Best Butt Plugs For 2021

In this guide, we’ll start with a quick rundown of the best butt plugs, then we’ll discuss how they work and why they're so popular, we'll then show you how we compared them and finally, we'll cover common questions.


Butt Plug



Best Overall

njoy Pure Play XL



Mood Naughty



Red Boy XL



Nexus Ace






Secret Shine






DOXY Smooth






Booty Call


The scores from this table are based on: size, shape, durability, materials used and ease of use.

Score: 97/100

njoy Pure Plug

Best Butt Plug

njoy Pure Plug XL

  • Tapered Head
  • Luxury Stainless Steel
  • Smooth, Yet Firm
  • Safe, Wide Base
  • Hand Polished
  • Easily Hits Prostate

Why buy njoy Pure Plug?

  1. Superior Packaging
    From the moment you open the premium metallic case, with its purple-silk inner lining, you'll realise that it was designed specifically to prove that anal play is not something to be ashamed or afraid of. Through their range, njoy seems to be single-handedly bringing anal play to a new level of acceptance simply by the quality of their products. It's safe to say that you won't be throwing the box away!
  2. Sizeable, Weighty Head
    The first thing you'll notice when you pick up the Pure Plug XL is its size and weight. Although the prospect of inserting the bulbous head into your anus may appear daunting at first, when you actually do it, you'll realise that the tapered tip makes insertion much easier. Once it’s in, it’s in and you can walk around confidently knowing it’s staying put and it feels incredible and surprisingly comfortable even when sitting down. 
  3. Smooth Metallic Finish
    The metallic finish is a large part of the reason why the njoy range is so comfortable. Normally, a larger butt plug would be inaccessible for intermediate level users, however the smooth feel from hours of hand-polishing makes this anal sex toy a real luxury to play with.
  4. Strong Thin Neck
    The next thing you'll notice is how thin the neck is; normally butt plugs have short, thick necks to prevent any risk of breakage inside of you. However, that comes with a sacrifice, butt plugs with that level of thickness aren't very comfortable on your anus and can cause your butt checks to snag or chafe. The strong, metallic build quality of the njoy means that you can enjoy a feeling of fullness without any of the drawbacks.
  5. Wide Base / Handle
    The njoy plug has a looped handle which offers excellent control even when its covered in lubricant. If you're sitting down while wearing it, a mere shift in where you place your weight will allow you to stimulate your prostate causing immense pleasure. Additionally, the handle acts as the safety mechanism, preventing a huge lump of metal from being absorbed inside your bum. Bum fun should never end in the hospital!
  6. Works During Sex
    Since you have no fear of it falling out, the njoy works exceptionally well in any position you choose. However, it's particularly enjoyable when you're behind your partner in doggy position; the thrusting motion causes the plug to move back and fore inside of you, massaging your prostate and giving you even more pleasure.
  7. Easy To Clean
    An excellent side-effect of the smooth, metal finish is how easy the njoy toys are to clean; just run them over hot water, give them a spray of your favourite anal sex toy cleaner and place it back in the box for the next time you use it.
  8. Use Throughout The Day
    Once you've some practice with the njoy at home, if you're feeling brave, you can experiment with wearing it out in public. With every step, you'll notice the weighty plug bouncing inside you, gently massaging your prostate which can result in some pleasant surprises! Additionally, the shape of the handle makes it comfortable to sit so there's no fear of needing to stand up all day long.
  9. Great For Temperature Play
    If the size and smooth finish isn't enough, you can heighten the stimulation levels by incorporating temperature play too. Simply apply some hot or cold water for around 60 seconds before use and you'll notice a world of difference.  The warmth helps to relax your sphincters, and then once it is in, it’s a bit like having a cup of hot soup on a cold day, you feel all warm on the inside. If you choose to go for the cold option, expect a trickier entry but a more intense feeling once inside.

Are there any downsides?

  1. Be Careful Of The Size
    Although the njoy is very smooth and has a tapered head, allowing easier entry, it is still pretty big so you do need lots of lube. If you're a beginner and concerned about removing it, the trick is to remain calm and relaxed while giving it a gentle push and pull. Take it very slowly and relaxed on first use, if unaccustomed to the size.
  2. It's Expensive
    Although the njoy is undoubtedly the top rated butt plug around, it's not cheap so if you're a newbie to butt plugs and wanting to try anal play for the first time then this may not be for you.

Score: 83/100

Mood Naughty

Best For Beginners

Mood Naughty

  • Easy To Insert/Remove
  • Only 3 Inches Big
  • Easy to use
  • Hypoallergenic
  • Tapered Tip
  • Beginner friendly

Why buy the Mood Naughty?

  1. Great Size For Newbies
    If you're entirely new to anal play then you're going to want to start with a butt plug that's small, thin and easy to insert and remove. Essentially, it's just noticeable enough to feel like something is there, teasing the anal nerve endings and no more. The Mood Naughty is perfect for those purposes.
  2. Gentle On Skin
    It's made from soft hypoallergenic silicone, ensuring that you don't feel overwhelmed with pressure.
  3. Curved Base
    The curved base of the Mood Naughty makes it really easy to put your fingers around so you can insert and remove with ease. Additionally, it will give you a light stimulus around your anus too.

Are there any downsides?

The Mood Naughty is a great anal plug to get you started, however it's unlikely to give you the intense pleasure levels that you seek. For that reason, you're likely to graduate to a larger plug quite quickly.

Score: 72/100

Red Boy XL

Largest Butt Plug

Red Boy XL

  • 6.5 Inches
  • Strong Flared Base
  • Smooth Insertion
  • Guaranteed Gape
  • Very Sturdy
  • Challenging

Why buy the Red Boy XL?

  1. Awesome For Advanced Anal Fiends
    If you're turned on by the prospect of having your anal cavity filled to the brim then the Red Boy XL is the best option for you. It's one of the biggest anal plugs on the market and is guaranteed to result in a gaping anus. Wearing this device while your partner rides on top of you is especially enjoyable. Expect a little pain at the same time, but this fades quickly and turns into pleasure.
  2. High Levels Of Tapering
    The tip is highly tapered which means that inserting the Red Boy XL isn't an all-or-nothing kind of deal and you can gradually work up to greater depths.
  3. Wide Base For Safety
    It's important to note that the base is extremely large and chunky which is ideal as it prevents this enormous toy from being swallowed up by your anus.

Are there any downsides?

As with any large butt plug, it can be a little challenging to remove after you've finished using it. However, if you're an advanced user then this should be no news to you.

Score: 93/100

Nexus Ace

Vibrating Butt Plug

Nexus Ace

  • Highly Stimulating
  • Can Use While Seated
  • Range Of Pulses
  • Splash-Proof
  • Battery Operated
  • Well Proportioned

Why buy the Nexus Ace?

  1. Highly Stimulating
    If you enjoy the pleasure of an anal plug but aren't satisfied with its natural motion alone inside you as you walk around or thrust on your partner then vibration is a must. The stimulus you get inside your rectum is an intense distraction, reverberating around your whole body, allowing you to experience a new type of orgasm. 
  2. Range Of Pulses
    Having vibrations inside you is exciting, however if it's just the same thing all the time then you'll soon get used to them. The Nexus Ace has 6 different vibrating modes meaning you'll never get bored. Whenever you feel like you're getting used to one of the modes, press the 'next' button and you'll be right back to ecstasy. 
  3. Remote Controlled
    Many vibrating butt plugs are difficult to control during use; you need to stop your session and fiddle around with the base unit which can be highly distracting. The Nexus Ace's remote controller saves you from that hassle. Just press the button to choose the mode you like and the intensity you want and you're all set. Even better, give your partner the controller to give you a surprise orgasm!
  4. Re-Chargeable
    There's nothing more frustrating than being at the edge of climax, but just before you explode, the batteries run out and the fun ends abruptly. The reason this happens is that most vibrating anal plugs operate using AA or AAA batteries and do not alert you when they're nearly finished. Instead, the Nexus Ace recharges itself with a USB socket - so you don't have to continuously buy more! 
  5. It's Quiet
    One of the joys of wearing a vibrating butt plug is being able to wear it in public and have your partner control it with the remote. It's naughty and thrilling at the same time. However, if someone hears the vibrating noises coming from your direction, the gig will be up and you may as well be masturbating in front of them. The quiet vibrations from the Nexus Ace keep your fun discreet and alive!

Are there any downsides?

Although the Nexus Ace is a great option if you want to up your vibrating anal game, it isn't designed to hit your p-spot.

If you're looking for a device specifically for that then consider a prostate massager - click here for more info.

Score: 93/100

Rocker by ElectraStim

Electrified Plug


  • Easy To Insert
  • Hands-Free Pleasure
  • Range Of Pulses
  • Splash-Proof
  • Battery Operated
  • Well Proportioned

Why buy the ElectraStim Rocker?

  1. Safety
    When buying an electro butt plug, it's critical that you choose a device that is safe and it's clear from the get-go that the ElectraStim has gone to extra lengths to protect you. Made from platinum cured, medical grade silicone you can rest assured that the materials used to create this device won't harm you. Additionally, the comfortable base makes rocking easy and once you're finished, all you need to do is put your hands around the t-bar and pull it out.
  2. Easy Insertion
    The vertical grooves and flexibility of the ElectraStim make it insertion especially easy and goes to the right position immediately without needing to mess about with it.
  3. Electric Stimulation
    Of course, the main benefit of choosing this particular butt plug is the heightened sensations you get from the stimulation of all of your nerve endings in your rectum at once! At the low settings, just expect a little tingle, but as you increase it you'll be in for quite a thrill as your muscles contract and relax on their own accord.
  4. Rock Back And Forth
    Unlike many electro stimulating butt plugs, the Electrastim Rocker is specifically designed to allow you to wear it while sitting down. By having the plug in points on the side of the butt plug rather than underneath it means they won't be damaged by your rocking motions.
  5. Easy To Clean
    Clean up is relatively easy - just unplug it from the power supply and wash it with anal sex toy cleaner and soapy water. Make sure you don't submerge it though as it will damage the device.

Are there any downsides?

  1. With the ElectraStim, you're going to need a power supply called an EM60 Flick Unit which costs extra.
  2. You can't use it under water due to the external power supply
  3. It isn't the easiest to use while walking around in public.

Score: 72/100

Secret Shine

Jeweled Plug

Secret Shine

  • No batteries
  • Ribbed edges
  • Multiple stimulus points
  • Doesn't fall out
  • Velvet touch
  • Discreet shipping

Why buy the Secret Shine?

  1. Sparkly jeweled Base
    An underrated element of butt plugs is their appearance. Commonly hidden away, while in use, they do not get the attention they deserve. However, when you wear a jeweled plug, things change dramatically. Simply knowing that you're wearing something sparkly is enough to enhance your experience ten-fold. Better still, if you catch a glance of yourself in the mirror, it'll be hard to contain the excitement!
  2. Satisfying Size
    Although the jewel itself is the most critical factor when making your choice, it's important to consider how it feels too. And the Secret Shine does not compromise! The 3.5 inches available to insert within you is more than enough to tantalize your nerve endings and give you an impressive orgasm.
  3. Temperature Responsive
    Few people realise the benefits of adding a little temperature change to your butt play and so they miss out. The Secret Shine's zinc finish allows it to easily adopt the warmth or coolness that you place it in.

Are there any downsides?

None - if you're looking for a jeweled butt plug then the Secret Shine is your best bet!

Score: 72/100

​​Chrystalino Review

Glass Butt Plug


  • Temperature Sensitive
  • Tapered Tip
  • Satisfying Size
  • Hand-Blown Glass
  • Beginner Friendly
  • Easy Insertion

Why buy the Chrystalino?

  1. Great Alternative To Metallic Plugs
    If you like the idea of using a temperature-sensitive butt plug but don't fancy putting metal in your butt then you should definitely consider using glass option, particularly the Chrystalino. Simply put it in the fridge before you start playing and after 10 minutes, it'll be ready to give you an intense level of pleasure unlike anything else.
  2. Satisfying Size
    Although the Chrystalino is better for temperature control, it's still a great size for people who want to feel full inside.
  3. Shatterproof
    From a safety standpoint, it's crucial that any glass butt plug is shatterproof. The last thing you want is for it to snap inside you and cause an embarrassing hospital visit. With the Chrystalino, you can rest assured that you'll be safe.

Are there any downsides?

No - the Chyrstalino is an exceptional choice if glass is your thing.

Score: 92/100

Doxy Smooth

Metallic Butt Plug

DOXY Smooth

  • Temperature Sensitive
  • Intermediate Users
  • Sleek Aluminum Finish
  • Wide Flared Base
  • Suitable For Long Use
  • Sit-friendly

Why buy the DOXY Smooth?

  1. Premium Finish
    The appearance of the DOXY Smooth alone is enough to turn any anal lover on. The smooth, polished reflective finish will instantly have you excited to experiment with it.
  2. Temperature Sensitive
    As with all metallic butt plugs, it is temperature sensitive. This means you can put it in the fridge or warm water to heighten your sensations even more.
  3. Mid-Size For Intermediate Users
    The 4 inch insertion length is perfect if you've had a bit of experience with anal toys already and are ready to graduate to the next level.
  4. Sit-Friendly
    If you enjoy having your partner ride on top of you then the DOXY Smooth will be a good choice for you - its flared base makes it comfortable even when you're sitting down.

Are there any downsides?

Although it's an awesome weight and size for people with a bit of experience using anal plugs, if you're looking for something larger then you might want to consider the njoy Pure Plug XL.

Score: 92/100


Best Tail Plug

DOMINIX Deluxe Fox Tail

  • Great For Role Play
  • Faux Fur
  • Easy To Wash
  • Medium-Sized
  • Metallic Plug
  • Stays In Comfortably

Why the DOMINIX Deluxe Fox Tail?

  1. Excellent For Role Play
    If you want to unleash your animalistic side upon your partner then the DOMINIX fox tail butt plug is the perfect way to do it. Just insert the plug, as normal, and you can swish the tail around across their body and face. It'll be just as much a turn on for them as it is for you.
  2. Faux Fur
    Although it's great being able to realise your fantasy, know that no real animals were hurt in the making of this tail will put karma on your side!
  3. Easy To Wash
    The tail can be easily screwed off, allowing you to wash the anal plug separately.
  4. Medium Size For Intermediate Users
    It's a decent size allowing it to sit comfortably inside, giving you pleasure without falling out.

Are there any downsides?

As with any butt plug, you need to apply a generous amount of lubrication. However, you've got to be careful to keep it away from the tail.

Score: 92/100

Best Butt Plugs For Men Reviewed 81

Inflatable Butt Plug

Booty Call

  • Choose Your Ideal Size
  • Up To 8.5 Inches
  • Effortless Inflation
  • Hands-Free
  • Base Sticks To Wall
  • Sit-friendly

Why buy the Booty Call?

  1. Choose Your Size
    If you want a butt plug but aren't sure how big you like it then the Booty Call is a great solution to that problem.
  2. Easy Inflation Pump
    All you need to do is squeeze on the hand pump a few times and it increases in size. There's also a value that you can use to let the air out if it gets too big.
  3. Suction Base
    The suction base is extremely useful as it allows you to stick the Booty Call to the bathroom wall so you can use it at varying heights.

Are there any downsides?

Bare in mind when using the pump tube where you stick the base to as the tubing isn't the most flexible.

How butt plugs work

What to consider when buying a butt plug

If you're new to the world of anal plugs, it can be difficult deciding which one to buy. In this section, we'll discuss each of the different features in order of importance.


There are a whole range of different shapes of available depending on the type of plug you choose. However, there's one key thing you should consider - tip tapering.

When you insert a butt plug into your anus, you want it to enter easily. For that reason, it needs to be a comfortable blend of being pointed yet round.

Size & Width

As with any anal sex toy, it's important that you consider size and width before buying. If you're a less experienced user then I'd suggest going for something smaller and working your way up.

Some people go ahead and buy the biggest butt plug they can find and it's too uncomfortable to use.

Materials Used

​All sorts of materials have been used to create these toys ranging from glass to wood, ​stainless steel, aluminium, plastic and silicone.

Metal, silicone and glass are, in our opinion, the best choice to go for as they are easiest to clean: just put them in hot water and you're good to go.

Can using a butt plug cause problems?

There are a couple of situations where you can cause yourself damage through the use of a butt plug. We'll discuss them now: 

  1. Sharp, dirty nails: if you (or your partner) have particularly sharp nails, it can irritate the inside of your anus during the initial preparation stage. Make sure they are well-trimmed and cleaned before getting started.
  2. Lack of lubricant: the anus is not self-lubricating so it's imperative that you use plenty of lubrication prior to insertion. If you do not use enough, it can result in irritation.
  3. When butt plugs are too big: if you select a device that is too large for your anus then it can be uncomfortable.